The Crooked Treehouse
  • Tips From The Bar
  • Honest Conversation Is Overrated
  • Popcorn Culture
  • Comically Obsessed
  • Justify Your Bookshelves
  • Storefront

How I Read Batman 5.1: Dead To Rights

6/16/2014

0 Comments

 
One of the things that I find super jarring in many of the 80s and early 90s comics, is how committed they are to making the stories feel "fresh" by including pop culture references that cement them in an era. They are always clunky, and make the stories feel prematurely dated.

Batman: Dead To Rights is rife with references to Gray's Anatomy and Gnarls Barkley. It's not even a decade after this title came out, and it already feels archaic.

The idea is that this story picks up directly after The Joker is arrested for the first time (which could be after The Man Who Laughs or Lovers And Madmen). Instead of focusing on how The Joker is a dangerous criminal, it focuses on how The Joker is a dangerous prisoner. It's an interesting concept, hampered by the dialogue. You can tell Andrew Kreisberg is a television writer (he went on to create and write for Arrow), as some of his dialog would work better on the small screen. 

I didn't know Kreisberg wrote Arrow until I was composing this blog entry but it does make sense to me, as I think both Arrow and this storyarc are well-conceived ideas that creatively rewrite a major DC character's backstory. I also believe they bot fall victim to trying to do too much with characters that I don't think he and I understand the same way. This version of The Joker is too snappy standup comedian for me, similarly in the way Kreisberg's Oliver Queen is too dark and broody for me.

(All that said, I adore Kreisberg's take on The Flash universe, and find it superior to almost every issue of The Flash I've ever read.)

We get some cameos of future GCPD characters, as well as one of the greatest one page uses of The Riddler that I've seen.

We also get the first appearance of Matches Malone (Bruce Wayne's alter alter ego) but in a very unsatisfying scene that makes it appear that Gotham Police don't even bother a gentle pat-down of incoming prisoners, as Matches has the entire Batman outfit, including the utility belt in his possession when The Joker see through the Malone identity.

Scott McDaniel's artwork is very busy with quite a bit of panel busting, but that makes sense for a Joker story. I'm not in love with some of his repeated facial expressions, but I also think that may be a purposeful statement on some of the characters.

Story 2/5. Art 4/5.
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.


    January 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    November 2023
    September 2023
    February 2023
    December 2022
    July 2022
    December 2021
    May 2020
    April 2019
    December 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    September 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    November 2015
    October 2015
    October 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014

    Subjects

    All
    Alan Davis
    Alan Grant
    Alfred
    Aquaman
    Avengers
    Barbara Gordon
    Barry Windsor Smith
    Batman
    Batmite
    Bizarro
    Black Panther
    Blockbuster
    Books Of Magic
    Boone
    Brian K Vaughan
    Brian Michael Bendis
    Brother Blood
    Brotherhood Of Evil
    Bryan Talbot
    Calendar Man
    Carmen Infantino
    Catwoman
    Chris Bachalo
    Chuck Dixon
    Dan Didio
    Daniel Way
    Dan-slott
    Daredevil
    Dave Gibbons
    Dave McKean
    David Mazzucchelli
    Deadman
    Deathstroke
    Dennis O'Neil
    Dick Grayson Robin
    Doug Mahnke
    Ed Brubaker
    Falcones
    Fantastic Four
    Francis Manapaul
    Frank Miller
    Geoff Johns
    George Perez
    Grant Morrison
    Green Lantern
    Gregory Wright
    Greg Pak
    G Willow Wilson
    Harley Quinn
    Harvey Dent
    Hellblazer
    Hellboy
    Holiday
    Hugo Strange
    Jack Kirby
    James Robinson
    Jason Aaron
    Jason Todd Robin
    Jenny Noblesse
    Jeph Loeb
    Jim Gordon
    Jj Birch
    J Michael Straczynski
    Joe Chill
    John Byrne
    John Constantine
    John Romita JR
    Jonathan Hickman
    Judd Winnick
    Julie Madison
    Justice League
    Keith Giffen
    Kelly Sue Deconnick
    Kieron Gillen
    Klaus Janson
    Kurt Busiek
    Leslie Thompkins
    Lucius Fox
    Man-bat
    Manga
    Mark Millar
    Mark Waid
    Marv Wolfman
    Matt Fraction
    Matt Wagner
    Mike Allred
    Mike Barr
    Mike Carey
    Mike Mignola
    Mindy Newell
    Mr. Freeze
    Mr. Whisper
    Neal Adams
    Neil Gaiman
    Norman Madison
    Paul J Tomasi
    P Craig Russell
    Peter J Tomasi
    Poison Ivy
    Ras Al Ghul
    Rick Remender
    Robert Kirkman
    Ron Marz
    Roy Thomas
    Sal Maroni
    Sandman
    Shrike
    Solomon Grundy
    Stan Lee
    Superman
    Teen Titans
    The Flash
    The Joker
    The Killer Moth
    The Mad Hatter
    The Monk
    The Penguin
    The Reaper
    The Riddler
    The Scarecrow
    The Vigilante
    Tim Sale
    Todd Macfarlane
    Two Face
    Ultimate Universe
    Valiant Comics
    Vertigo
    Warren Ellis
    Wonder Woman
    XMen
    Young Justice Cartoon

    RSS Feed

All work on the Crooked Treehouse is ©Adam Stone, except where indicated, and may not be reproduced without his permission. If you enjoy it, please consider giving to my Patreon account.
  • Tips From The Bar
  • Honest Conversation Is Overrated
  • Popcorn Culture
  • Comically Obsessed
  • Justify Your Bookshelves
  • Storefront